Join thousands of students who trust us to help them ace their exams!Watch the first video
Multiple Choice
Which of the following types of evidence is most important when determining whether a trait is an adaptation?
A
Noting that the trait is similar to those found in unrelated species
B
Observing that the trait is present in all individuals of the species
C
Finding that the trait is genetically inherited
D
Demonstrating that the trait increases the organism's fitness in its environment
Verified step by step guidance
1
Understand the concept of an adaptation: An adaptation is a trait that has evolved through natural selection because it provides a fitness advantage in a specific environment. Fitness refers to an organism's ability to survive and reproduce.
Evaluate the first option: 'Noting that the trait is similar to those found in unrelated species.' This is not sufficient evidence for an adaptation because similar traits in unrelated species could result from convergent evolution, not necessarily from a fitness advantage in the same environment.
Evaluate the second option: 'Observing that the trait is present in all individuals of the species.' While this might suggest the trait is important, it does not confirm that the trait increases fitness. It could be a neutral trait or one that is simply widespread due to genetic drift.
Evaluate the third option: 'Finding that the trait is genetically inherited.' While genetic inheritance is necessary for a trait to be an adaptation, it does not prove that the trait increases fitness. Many inherited traits are not adaptations.
Focus on the correct answer: 'Demonstrating that the trait increases the organism's fitness in its environment.' This is the most important evidence because it directly links the trait to an increase in survival and reproduction, which is the defining characteristic of an adaptation.