Skip to main content
Ch. 16 - Aromatic Compounds
Wade - Organic Chemistry 9th Edition
Wade9th EditionOrganic ChemistryISBN: 9780135213728Not the one you use?Change textbook
Chapter 16, Problem 36c

The benzene ring alters the reactivity of a neighboring group in the benzylic position much as a double bond alters the reactivity of groups in the allylic position.

Benzylic cations, anions, and radicals are all more stable than simple alkyl intermediates.
c. Which of the following reactions will have the faster rate and give the better yield? Use a drawing of the transition state to explain your answer.

Verified step by step guidance
1
Step 1: Analyze the two reactions provided. Reaction (i) involves a cyclohexyl group with a CH2Cl substituent, while reaction (ii) involves a benzyl group with a CH2Cl substituent. Both reactions proceed via nucleophilic substitution using NaOCH2CH3 in ethanol as the nucleophile and solvent.
Step 2: Consider the stability of the intermediate formed during the reaction. In reaction (ii), the benzyl group stabilizes the intermediate (whether cation, anion, or radical) due to resonance with the aromatic ring. This stabilization is absent in reaction (i), where the cyclohexyl group does not provide resonance stabilization.
Step 3: Draw the transition states for both reactions. For reaction (ii), the transition state will show partial resonance stabilization of the benzylic intermediate, while for reaction (i), the transition state lacks such stabilization. This difference impacts the activation energy of the reactions.
Step 4: Compare the rates of the reactions. The resonance stabilization in reaction (ii) lowers the activation energy, making the reaction faster compared to reaction (i). Additionally, the benzyl group enhances the yield due to the increased stability of the intermediate.
Step 5: Conclude that reaction (ii) will have a faster rate and better yield due to the stabilizing effect of the benzyl group in the benzylic position, which is supported by resonance stabilization in the transition state.

Verified video answer for a similar problem:

This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
Video duration:
10m
Was this helpful?

Key Concepts

Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.

Benzylic Position

The benzylic position refers to the carbon atom directly attached to a benzene ring. This position is significant because it exhibits unique reactivity patterns due to the resonance stabilization provided by the aromatic system. Reactions involving benzylic intermediates, such as cations, anions, and radicals, tend to be more favorable compared to those involving simple alkyl groups, leading to increased stability and reactivity.
Recommended video:
1:01
Reactions at Benzylic Positions Concept 1

Stability of Intermediates

In organic chemistry, the stability of reaction intermediates like cations, anions, and radicals is crucial for predicting reaction rates and outcomes. Benzylic cations, anions, and radicals are more stable than their non-aromatic counterparts due to resonance stabilization, which allows for delocalization of charge. This increased stability often results in faster reaction rates and better yields in reactions involving benzylic intermediates.
Recommended video:
Guided course
04:31
Stability of Conjugated Intermediates

Transition State Theory

Transition state theory describes the high-energy state that occurs during a chemical reaction, where reactants are transformed into products. The transition state is a critical point along the reaction pathway and determines the rate of the reaction. Understanding the structure of the transition state, especially in reactions involving benzylic positions, can provide insights into the reaction mechanism and help predict which reaction will proceed faster or yield better results.
Recommended video:
Guided course
06:55
Intermediates vs. Transition States
Related Practice
Textbook Question

Before spectroscopy was invented, Körner’s absolute method was used to determine whether a disubstituted benzene derivative was the ortho, meta, or para isomer. Körner’s method involves adding a third group (often a nitro group) and determining how many isomers are formed. For example, when o-xylene is nitrated (by a method shown in Chapter 17), two isomers are formed.

a. How many isomers are formed by nitration of m-xylene?

1094
views
Textbook Question

The benzene ring alters the reactivity of a neighboring group in the benzylic position much as a double bond alters the reactivity of groups in the allylic position.

Benzylic cations, anions, and radicals are all more stable than simple alkyl intermediates.

b. Toluene reacts with bromine in the presence of light to give benzyl bromide. Propose a mechanism for this reaction.

1777
views
Textbook Question

The benzene ring alters the reactivity of a neighboring group in the benzylic position much as a double bond alters the reactivity of groups in the allylic position.

Benzylic cations, anions, and radicals are all more stable than simple alkyl intermediates.

a. Use resonance forms to show the delocalization (over four carbon atoms) of the unpaired electron of the benzyl radical.

1274
views
Textbook Question

The benzene ring alters the reactivity of a neighboring group in the benzylic position much as a double bond alters the reactivity of groups in the allylic position.


Benzylic cations, anions, and radicals are all more stable than simple alkyl intermediates.

a. Use resonance forms to show the delocalization (over four carbon atoms) of the positive charge of the benzyl cation.

1387
views
Textbook Question

Before spectroscopy was invented, Körner’s absolute method was used to determine whether a disubstituted benzene derivative was the ortho, meta, or para isomer. Körner’s method involves adding a third group (often a nitro group) and determining how many isomers are formed. For example, when o-xylene is nitrated (by a method shown in Chapter 17), two isomers are formed.

c. A turn-of-the-century chemist isolated an aromatic compound of molecular formula C6H4Br2. He carefully nitrated this compound and purified three isomers of formula C6H3Br2NO2. Propose structures for the original compound and the three nitrated derivatives

642
views
Textbook Question

Before spectroscopy was invented, Körner’s absolute method was used to determine whether a disubstituted benzene derivative was the ortho, meta, or para isomer. Körner’s method involves adding a third group (often a nitro group) and determining how many isomers are formed. For example, when o-xylene is nitrated (by a method shown in Chapter 17), two isomers are formed.

b. How many isomers are formed by nitration of p-xylene?

831
views